Date: Mon Sep 12 1994 00:00:16 Subj: Roswell Report out UFO - Top-secret balloon - not a U

---
Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

Date: Mon Sep 12 1994 00:00:16 From: Sheppard Gordon Subj: Roswell Report out UFO ------------------------------- Top-secret balloon -- not a UFO -- crashed in N.M in 1947 Credit: Associated Press 09/09/94 WASHINGTON -- There will be no convincing some people, but the Air Force says -- again -- the thing that hit the ground near Roswell, N.M., in 1947 was not the proof that UFOs exist. But it did prove that a crashing balloon could make a 47-year mess. There were no secret autopsies on space aliens who couldn't fly too well. No flying saucer pieces under guard on an air base. No big conspiracy. It was just a balloon. One of ours. Sorry. It took eight months to reach that conclusion, and the Air Force hopes now to put to rest talk in UFO circles that military authorities covered up a grand extraterrestrial event. The Air Force began the investigation in January after Rep. Steven Schiff, R-N.M., asked the General Accounting Office, the investigative arm of Congress, to press the Pentagon to declassify documents relating to Roswell. Air Force officials tracked down principals, combed archives, and even sent some old news photos to the CIA for analysis -- all to try to deflate the persistent rumors of a massive government conspiracy to hide the truth. The effort produced a 25-page report, released yesterday, in which Col. Richard Weaver concludes that the debris a rancher found probably came from a once top-secret balloon designed to monitor the atmosphere for evidence of Soviet nuclear tests. Of the UFO theories, Colonel Weaver had this to say: "What is uniquely lacking in the entire exploration and exploitation of the Roswell Incident is official positive documentary or physical evidence of any kind that supports the claims of those who allege that something unusual happened." However, Colonel Weaver predicted "pro-UFO" elements simply would dismiss his report as part of the cover-up. Indeed, Walter Haut, a volunteer at the UFO Museum at Roswell, a center devoted to gathering information on this and other UFO incidents, wasted no time in rejecting the Air Force conclusions. In July 1947 the owner of a ranch near Roswell picked up debris that included scattered foil-coated fabric, sticks, rubber and some small I-beams with strange markings. Maj. Jesse Marcel, the Army Air Force intelligence officer who brought in the wreckage, was reported to have recovered a "flying disc." A local headline screamed that the Air Force "Captures Flying Saucer." All this coincided with a surge of interest in unidentified flying objects, purportedly from outer space. Days later, a higher-ranking officer identified the material as the remains of a weather balloon. But the seed of what became known as the Roswell Incident had been planted. There the matter stood until 1978 when the supermarket tabloid National Inquirer retold Major Marcel's story. A series of books followed advancing the UFO theory and accusing the Air Force of cover-up. The television show "Unsolved Mysteries" aired a re-creation of the Roswell incident. A made-for-TV movie is in the works. The original reports of a few foil scraps at one ranch site evolved into planeloads of material scattered over multiple debris fields. And the relatively simple materials found would later be described as exotic metals and fiber-optic materials. At a second site, according to some accounts, the Air Force found the bodies of extraterrestrials. All this was kept from the public by an elaborate conspiracy orchestrated by the Air Force, critics charge. The report counters the charges of UFO buffs with the same argument used against Kennedy assassination aficionados, that the conspiracy theories are too complicated, and involve too many supposed participants to be credible.

---

E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank