Date: Wed Jun 01 1994 00:00:28 To: All Subj: Abductions,SleepParalysi The Alien Notion 05/

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

Date: Wed Jun 01 1994 00:00:28 From: Sheppard Gordon To: All Subj: Abductions,SleepParalysi The Alien Notion 05/27/94 THE WASHINGTON POST Why do some people think they've been abducted by aliens from space? Normally, being calm and rational types, we greet tales of alien abduction with hoots, sneers and guffaws, then quickly return to our previous work on behalf of the Zorgon Empire. But lately the alien thing has gotten out of hand. Alien-abduction stories have gotten a big boost with the publication of a book by a well-known, Pulitzer Prize-winning Harvard psychiatrist, John Mack, who says he believes that these stories, however far-fetched, are actually true. Alien abduction is also a regular theme of allegedly nonfiction TV programs. Getting abducted by little gray men with large eyeballs is to the '90s what disco dancing in white suits was to the '70s. Maybe it's all true. How can you disprove it? The aliens are doing it secretly, remember, so the absence of footprints, photographs or direct alien confessions merely corroborates the scenario of a covert UFO operation. There are probably many factors at work here. Some stories are probably hoaxes. Some are probably the result of madness. A few may be artifacts of therapy, the misapplication of hypnosis or the implantation of false memories by pseudo-scientific investigators (psychiatrists, for example). Skeptics say memory is inherently malleable, particularly when a patient is undergoing the hypnosis technique known as "memory regression." "Without a doubt, inadvertent cueing also plays a major role in UFO-abduction fantasies. The hypnotist unintentionally gives away to the person being regressed exactly what response is wanted," psychologist Robert Baker has written in the Skeptical Inquirer. There's one explanation for UFO abductions that we find particularly intriguing. This is the theory that some abduction fantasies are a function of a sleeping disorder called sleep paralysis. It so happens that a key Why staffer has this very disorder, and, indeed, the symptoms match up with some of the symptoms of alien abduction. The aliens usually strike at night while people are in bed; so too does sleep paralysis. The abductees report that their first sensation is apprehension, the sense that someone is in the room; that is precisely what happens with sleep paralysis. Sleep paralysis is a screw-up of the brain's normal awake-asleep mechanism. Normally people lose muscle tone only when they are asleep. But if you have sleep paralysis this loss of muscle tone can kick in too early, before your brain is asleep, or persist after you've woken up. It's creepy! In fact it's a lot like being zapped with a suspended-animation ray from the Mother Ship. You have to shake yourself out of it, no easy task. All the while you tend to have auditory hallucinations or dreamlike thoughts, usually with menacing overtones. In Whitley Streiber's book "Communion" he describes waking up, being unable to move, seeing strange beings, then, incredibly, going back to sleep. Sounds just like sleep paralysis. Our Why staffer has never imagined himself abducted. But he has felt, during these sleep paralysis attacks, that they were being done to him by someone else, some Other. It's all the more frustrating then to realize, when the attack goes away, that it is just one's own self that is doing this, that the Other is just one's own brain. Okay, so maybe that's not as interesting an explanation for alien abduction as the one that says aliens are really here and are trying to beam us aboard their spacecraft so they can do unseemly alien things to us. But you have to admit it's almost as weird.


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank