On page D2 of the Waterloo Courier, in the Opinion section (The Courier is our local newsp

---
Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

On page D2 of the Waterloo Courier, in the Opinion section (The Courier is our local newspaper), Professor Scott Cawelti, who has written several articles in the past being rather critical of Christianity, wrote an article that really seemed like a slap in the face ... Well, since I have it with me, I'll just to some excerpts, starting from the beginning... THREE TRUE MEANINGS OF CHRISTMAS Every December without fail comes the chorus of complaints about Christmas: Too commercialized, too glitzy, too removed from "the" true meaning. It's a tradition, almost as predictable as the post-Thanksgiving dat shopping frenzy. Christians in particular seem to complain about their holiday. Some grow quite emotional about losing the small babe in the manger among the baubles and bangles of store-bought Christmas. In their letters, sermons, and even church advertising, they labor to remind us that Christmas exists solely because of that babe in the manger. He's the reason for the season, they proclaim. The true meaning of Christmas. Well, they're wrong. The pagan celebration of the winter solstice occurred long before Christians settled on December 25 for their holiday. In fact, according to at least two authorities -- Barbara Walker ("Women's Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets") and Vergilius Ferm ("Encyclopedia of Religion") -- for several hundred years, Christians had no idea when to celebrate Christmas. "According to authentic records," says Ferm, "no church festival was held in celebration of Christ's birth until the first half of the fourth century." And why did early churchmen choose Dec. 25? Because that's when most people *already* celebrated the winter solstice, a time-honored pagan festival. That's the longest night, and when the sun begins returning. The "son" returns, get it? "Norsemen celebrated the birthday of their lord, Frey, at the nadir of the sun in the darkest days of winter, known to them as Yule," says Walker. So the origins of Christmas aren't really Christian. None of the solstice celebrations were connected to the Christian church. "Yule logs, gifts, lights, mistletoe, holly, carols, feasts and processions were altogether pagan," notes Walker. "Christmas trees evolved from *pinea silva*, pine groves attached to temples of the Great Mother." But what better day to celebrate the birth of Jesus, since there was already a huge holiday then? Christians, after much debate and foot-dragging, appropriated the old pagan holiday as their own. So those lawn decorators who combine the babe in the manger with candy-cane lights and Santa Claus actually combine a couple of the true meanings of Christmas. More power to them, I say. To be accurate, there are at least three meanings to Christmas. None are more "true" than the others, in spite of all Christian protestations. First, there's the Christian Christmas. Let's be fair, after all. A babe born in a lowly manger destined to become a savior makes a great story. It's worth celebrating, even if it isn't the only true meaning. Any holiday that inspires people to think about the lowly becoming the mighty deserves serious attention. But just as true, and just as important, is the winter solstice. We do live in a climate that needs sun. Right about now we have the least sun possible for sustaining life. We get crabby from lack of light, the ground seems closer to granite than earth, winds howl nightly. It's a fairly miserable time, and beginning this week, the sun literally begins its return. If that's not worth celebrating, nothing is. Finally, and equally true, there's the spirit of giving that pervades the holiday, and always has among Christians and non-Christians alike. People tend to think of other people more at Christmas, thanks to the pagan tradition of gift-giving. As so many Christmas stories remind us (Scrooge, George Bailey, the Grinch) a happy, meaningful life hinges more on giving than receiving. 'Tis the season to be larger, both in mind and in spirit. So, I for one don't mind all the commercialization, since that's one of the true meanings of Christmas. I do mind one group trying to claim that they have a lock on "the" true meaning of Christmas. As Christians who know history must know (whether they deny it or not), jingle bells were around long before silent night.

---

E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank