RI Witch Coven Wins Tax Break PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) - Witchcraft is a legitimate religion
RI Witch Coven Wins Tax Break
PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) - Witchcraft is a legitimate religion and its
churches, or covens, are entitled to the same tax breaks as those of more
established religions, the state division of taxation has ruled.
``With this ruling, we witches will definitely be able to come out of the
closet and take our place in society,'' said Joyce Siegrist, 45, high
priestess of Rosegate Coven. She said the coven has a core group of 11 members
and 30 to 40 initiates.
The ruling announced Tuesday by Tax Administrator R. Gary Clark overturned
an earlier decision that said the coven did not meet criteria for being a
The coven, also known as Our Lady of the Roses Wiccan Church, will no
longer have to pay state sales tax for supplies.
``This decision demonstrates that, with a properly presented case, even
unusual or small religious groups can be treated equally with more mainstream
religions by the state,'' said A. Gregory Frazier, an American Civil Liberties
Union lawyer who announced the decision. He represented the witches in an
administrative hearing in May.
Hearing officer Sandra J. Murphy, who recommended that Clark grant the
exemption, ruled July 20 that the coven fulfilled most of the state Supreme
Court's criteria for determining the legitimacy of a religion.
The Wiccans are a nonprofit group, not set up for the purpose of avoiding
taxes, and have a litany or system of prayer, as well as specific doctrines
and practices that all members of the coven were expected to follow, Murphy
Last fall, when the tax exemption was denied, the division's questions
indicated that officials were focusing on the apparent lack of formal theology
schools for training wiccan clergy, and also on their willingness to allow
members to belong to other churches, Frazier said.
The latter argument was rebutted when the Rev. Thomas Ahlburn, senior
minister of the First Unitarian Church of Providence, testified that his
church and many Eastern religions also permit their members to belong to other
faiths, Frazier said.
(C) Copyright 1989, Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank