+quot;So... Which sex are you?+quot; +quot;I don't know. My doctor hasn't told me yet.+quo

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

"So... Which sex are you?" "I don't know. My doctor hasn't told me yet." _______________________________ (c) 1996 Baltimore Sun. All rts. reserv. WHAT ARE YOU: MALE, MERM, HERM, FERM OR FEMALE? BALTIMORE MORNING SUN (BS) - Sunday March 17, 1996 By: William O. Beeman Edition: F Section: Perspective Page: 1F Word Count: 1,054 TEXT: ARE THE CATEGORIES "man" and "woman" so obviously clear that they need no further explanation? Legislators throughout the nation trying to prevent the recognition of "gay marriage" contracted in other states obviously think so. They have introduced legislation that would grant official recognition only to marriages between "a man and a woman." Perhaps Mr. Burns and the other legislators who are pushing these bills don't realize it, but their passage would unwittingly nullify or prevent millions of supposedly heterosexual marriages. Why? Because the marriage partners will not meet the medical definition of being "a man and a woman." To make matters worse, most of these couples will not know that they are illegally married. Between 3 million and 10 million Americans are neither male nor female at birth. Additionally, as adults they may be genetically of the opposite gender from that which they and their parents believe them to be. The medical term for persons of ambiguous gender is "intersexual." Estimates of the numbers of persons who may be born intersexual ranges from 1 percent to 4 percent of all children born today, according to Dr. Anne Fausto-Sterling of the Division of Biology and Medicine at Brown University. The difficulty in determining clear-cut specification of gender arises because there are at least three ways to define it. Two are biological and one is cultural. The first biological definition defines gender in terms of chromosomes. Males have an X and a Y chromosome. Females have two X chromosomes. The second biological definition assigns gender in terms of male and female genitalia. In the third, "cultural" definition, males are people who lookand act "male," and females are people who look and act "female." Americans generally want everyone to fit the third, cultural definition, even when people have biological characteristics that are not strictly in accord with a two-gender system. One cause of intersexuality seems to be the posession of an abnormal number of chromosomes only one or more than two. A second cause stems from the fact that all humans, no matter what their chromosomal makeup, have the biological capacity to develop either male or female genitalia and secondary sexual characteristics while in the womb. Developmentally, some babies are born with male or female chromosomal makeup and with both male and female genitalia, or with some of the genitalia of the opposite chromosomal sex. Dr. Fausto-Sterling points out that there is a smooth continuum between 100 percent biologically male and 100 percent biologically female with many possibilities in between. She calls those with both testes and ovaries "herms." Those with testes and some female genitalia but no ovaries are "merms." Those with ovaries and some male genitalia but no testes are "ferms." This gives the possibility of five rough biological groupings: male, merm, herm, ferm and female. Most intersexual Americans are unaware of their true biological gender because under current medical practice, physicians reassign the gender of intersexual infants at birth. Such infants are surgically altered and given hormonal treatments so that they will fit into one of the two "cultural" categories male or female. The test is usually not chromosomal, but rather based on the "viability" of the genitalia to eventually appear normal. Often the parents are not fully informed about what is happening to their children. Dr. Fausto-Sterling calls this medical reassignment a "surgical shoehorn" designed to force intersexed infants into rigid cultural categories that have little to do with biological reality. As a result, there are perhaps millions of XX males and XY females living in the United States today. These are cultural males with male genitalia who are genetically female, and cultural females with female genitalia who are genetically male. The film star Jamie Lee Curtis is one well-known individual who is genetically male, but phenotypically female. The legislators have obviously not consulted with scientists in their zeal to eliminate "gay marriage." William O. Beeman is an associate professor of anthropology at Brown University. Pub Date: 3/17/96


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank