Subject: Permo/Triassic quandary O.K. I went back to the library and read the article (fro

---
Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

From: James G. Acker Subject: Permo/Triassic quandary Organization: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center - Greenbelt, MD USA O.K. I went back to the library and read the article (from the N.Y. Times) closely. Basically, the investigators used ion microprobe dating analysis (SHRIMP) of zircons from the Noril'sk I intrusion. The analysis provided a date of 251.6 +/- 3.6 million years for the Noril'sk I intrusion. According to the article, the Siberian Trap volcanism occurred for approximately 600,000 years. I copied the article in case questions arise. "Synchronism of the Siberian Traps and the Permian-Triassic Boundary", I.H. Campbell, G.K. Czamanske, V.A. Fedorenko, R.I. Hill, and V. Stepanov, _Science_ Vol. 258, 11 Dec 92. Now here's the fun stuff. Czamanske also presented at the AGU and has an abstract in _EOS_, entitled "The Siberian Traps: A Flip of the Dynamo and 600,000 Years of Hell on Earth". The eruptions all appear to have occurred in one 600,000 year interval, as alluded to earlier. Thought to have been caused by a mantle plume. He also notes the K/T event and the P/Tr event need not have a common cause (quoting Holser and Magaritz, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 1992, 56, 3297-3309. Because... the article ALSO notes that Rampino and Oberbeck propose an asteroid impact for the Permian/Triassic boundary, causing the breakup of Gondwanaland and puncturing the crust, allowing the Siberian Trap volcanism! Czamanske is quoted in the article as skeptical. Here's the Rampino abstract from _EOS_ (all this was going on at the meeting and I was doing oceanography!): (Sorry, I wrote ahead. The _Times_ article put Rampino with Oberbeck, but the paper was authored by Oberbeck, Marshall, and Agarwal): "Did Impacts Initiate Breakup of Gondwanaland?" Impacts (1,2,3,4) may have triggered flood basalt eruptions and they may have caused crustal rifting (3,4). Additionally, volcanic Precambrian greenstone belts may have resulted from partial melting of mantle sources after impacts (1). Formation of impact basins before 3.9 Ga may have formed vast basalt flows and initiated crustal rifting (2,3). Impacts may even have initiated formation of mantle plumes (3,4). We propose that tillites/diamictites provide clues to the role of impacts in Gondwanaland flood basalt volcanism and rifting. During Carboniferous and Permian time, extensive tillite/diamictite deposits were formed on the interior of Gondwanaland and this was followed by the most extensive eruption of flood basalts in geologic history and by the breakup of Gondwanaland. Textures of tillites/diamictites resemble those of impact craters (5,6,7) and the thickness distribution of tillites/diamictites produced in the last 2 billion years is the same as that predicted from impact models (6,8,9). This suggests that some tillites/diamictites could be of impact origin. Flood basalts postdate, and are associated spatially, with tillites and diamictites on the interior of Gondwanaland. We suggest that a long sequence of impact cratering preceding breakup of Gondwanaland could have extensively fractured the crust, triggered flood basalt eruptions, and facilitated final continental fragmentation. (1) Green, 1972, Earth. Plan. Sci. Lett. 15, 263-270. (2) Frey, 1980, Precam Res. 10, 195-216. (3) Grieve 1980, Precam Res. 10, 217-247. (4) Alt et al. 1988, J. Geol 96, 647-662. (5) Oberbeck & Marshall, 1992, LPSC XXIII, 1013-1014. (6) Oberbeck et al., 1992, J. Geol (in press) (7) Marshall and Oberbeck, 1992, AGU Abstr., this volume. (8) Oberbeck and Aggarwal, 1992, LPSC XXIII, 1011-1012. (9) Aggarwal and Oberbeck, 1992, AGU Abstr., this volume. Marshall and Oberbeck, the previous abstract, discusses terrestrial impact geology -- Ries crater Bunte Breccia, the Caribbean region of Chicxlub (the K/T "smoking gun") and an area in Australia.

---

E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank