I hope you take the time to actually read this. By : David Nash Dept. Of Chemistry Univ. o

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

I hope you take the time to actually read this. By : David Nash Dept. Of Chemistry Univ. of illinois We seem to have another pupil of the Michael Courtney school of atmospheric physics. First, clouds and water vapor are far less dense than liquid water. In the case of water vapor at (say) 25 C and 1 atmosphere pressure, liquid water is more dense than water vapor by a factor of 1370. To get enough water to flood the Earth to 6 miles deep (the height of Mt. Everest, plus a little more for good measure), you'd need a vapor layer roughly 1370x as deep as that 6 miles, or 8200 miles. Fat chance. Actually, this does neglect the inevitable compression of the stuff, which would show a pressure gradient like that of the Earth's current atmosphere. Even with this taken into account, though, you're still talking about at least tens of miles of water vapor at a density vastly exceeding anything ever recorded in the Earth's atmosphere. Clouds are denser than water vapor, since the consist of small droplets of liquid water, but they are still vastly less dense than the liquid. Next, there is the problem of air pressure. Those six miles of water don't magically become less massive by just being vaporized and suspended in the air. Next, there is the problem of heat of condensation, when all that water condenses to rain down. Going back to the Flood Fest of last fall, the amount of water required to cover the Earth to the depth of Everst is 4.5E9 km^3. This is 4.5E21 kg, and the energy this releases on condensing is (2260 kJ/kg) * 4.5E21 kg = 1.02E25 kJ = 1.02E28 J. By contrast, the Earth receives 5.52E24 J per YEAR from the Sun. Neat trick -- a flood that hits the Earth with as much energy as it gets from centuries of solar radiation. ========================================================================= By : Marty Leipzig A Phd Geologist If, for no other reason to educate some and irritate others, what follows is a mathematical treatise on the impossibility of a Biblical Great Flood... In order to flood the Earth to the Biblical depth of "10 cubits" above the highest mountains of the Earth; you would need some 4.427 billion cubic kilometers of water. The mass of this water would be 4.427 x 10^21 kilograms. The current amount of water in the Earth's hydrosphere is only 1.37 billion cubic kilometers. So, where did the other 2 hydrospheres full of water come from? It could not come from water vapor (or clouds) because the atmospheric pressure would be 842 times greater than it is now. Further, the latent heat relaeased when the vapor condenses into liquid would be enough to raise the temperature of the Earth's atmosphere to 3,570 C (6,458 F). Someone once suggested that a "Vapor Canopy" covered the Earth, and this is where all that water came from. Not so at all. What would keep that water in orbit above the Earth? This niggling little property called gravity would cause it to fall. Why should that take 40 days and 40 nights? Further, this mass of water (some 4.427 X 10^21 Kg) stores a tremendous amount of potential energy which would be converted to kinetic energy when the water falls and would be converted to heat when it strikes the Earth. This potential energy (Ep=M*g*H; where M=mass of water, g=gravitational constant and H=height of water above the Earth's surface) could be calculated. If 4.427 x 10^21 is divided by 40 days, it yields 1.107 x 10^20 Kg/day. If H=16,000m (approximately 10 miles), the released energy, per day, would equal 1.735 x 10^25 joules. The amount of energy the Earth would have to radiate per m^2/s is energy divided by surface area of the Earth times the number of seconds in one day; thus: Ep=1.735 x 10^25/(4*3.14159*((6386)^2)*86,400) = 391,935.096 j/m^2/s. The Earth currently radiates 215 j/m^2/s at an average temperature of 280 K. Using the Stephan-Boltzmann fourth power law to calculate temperature increase: E(increase)/E(normal)=T^4(increase)/T^4(normal); so E(normal) = 215 E(increase) = 391,935.096 T(normal) = 280 (turn the crank, and...) ---------------------- T(increase) = 1,800 K. The temperature of the Earth would have to rise 1,800 degrees. Further, the water level would rise an average of 14 cm. per minute for 40 days. In 13 minutes, the water level would be over 2 m. in depth. Further, water under standard pressure would not exist as a liquid at 1,800 K. So much for that flood...


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank