Micheal Cranford Our mainframe has been unable to post news articles for a few months. Thi

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

Micheal Cranford ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our mainframe has been unable to post news articles for a few months. This is a repost of an article that I sent (unsuccessfully) some time ago. I hope that you will not find it too dated. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- TITLE : Creationists' Credentials (or is Ignorance really Bliss) In a recent article allenroy@rigel.cs.pdx.edu (Callen Roy) writes: "Here is a fairly complete listing ICR faculty and their degrees, taken from the 1987-1988 ICR Graduate School catalog. I have added, in parentheses, the fields in which they received their degrees, whenever I was able find this information." [ deleted stuff addressed below ] "[ ... ] * Bliss, Richard B....................Director of Curriculum Development ....................Chairman of Science Education Dept. [ ... ] Ed.D. (Science Education Emphasis), University of Sarasota, 1978 [ ... ]" The University of Sarasota is a nonaccredited diploma mill with no campus and is located in a Florida motel. Bliss wrote his "doctoral thesis" on the "two-model" teaching of origins. He has accused evolutionary scientists of "intellectual dishonesty" and insists that he is "a recognized expert in the field of science education". Note that Bliss claims that he received his M.A. in 1972 and not in 1978 as you have indicated above. [1] By the way, you seem to have missed Dr. Harold Slusher at the ICR. Slusher claims to have an honorary D.Sc from Indiana Christian University and a Ph.D from Columbia Pacific University. Indiana Christian is a Bible College with a 1/2 man graduate science department (one person for both math and science) and Columbia Pacific is nonaccredited. [2] On a related note, Dr. Kelly Seagraves of the Creation Science Research Center (CSRC - a bitter rivel of the ICR) claimed to have both an M.A. and a D.Sc until 1981. After exposure his D.Sc suddenly changed to D.R.E. (doctor of religious education). He claims that his M.A. is from Sequoia University although a search for that school proved fruitless. The closest match was a Sequoia College, which offers 2 year associate degrees (and has no record of Seagraves). He insists that his D.Sc was honorary from Christian University. A computer search shows that school to be located in Jakarta, Indonesia. [1] Dr. Clifford Burdick (CSRC) claims to have a Ph.D in geology from the University of Physical Sciences in Phoenix Arizona. Unfortunately, neither the Phoenix telephone book nor the State of Arizona Board of Regents has the faintest idea where the school is located. [1] Dr. Carl Baugh claims to be an archaeologist with a Ph.D from the California Graduate School of Theology in Glendale. The Western Association of Schools and Colleges says this school is nonaccredited (not to mention that theology was expelled from science over 400 years ago). [3] "[ ... ] You'll note that some very well-known and respected universities are represented. [ ... ]" I have personally met creationists from both MIT and Stanford. This does not make creationism scientific, but rather shows just how immune some people are to education. If, for example, someone with a Ph.D in astronomy were to claim that the sun orbits the earth [5], geocentrism would not suddenly become scientific. Having a degree is no guarantee of competence in any particular field. I personally know someone with a degree in physics who is unable to calculate points on a circle using sines and cosines (and who incidentally also endorses astrology and biorhythms). Donald Chittick (physical chemist, George Fox College, Newberg, Oregon) [6] claims that the lack of helium in the earth's atmosphere proves that the earth is only about 10,000 years old. You would expect a chemist to know that the earth's gravity is not strong enough to keep any really light (low mass) gas from continually escaping into space. "[ ... ] a * marks the professors who were once Evolutionists. [ ... ]" The claims that some creationists make about having once been evolutionists are largely regarded as specious since these people relentlessly misrepresent evolution. They are also unable to give any kind of coherent definition of science. During the 1982 "Balanced Treatment of Creation-Science [sic] and Evolution-Science Act" trial in Little Rock Arkansas, W. Scott Morrow (chemist, Wofford College, South Carolina) claimed to have once been an evolutionist and rambled for more than an hour about how closed minded evolutionary scientists were. When Judge Overton asked him for just one example of a scientifically valid creationist paper's having been rejected, Morrow was unable to respond but went on to imply that the entire international scientific community was engaged in a conspiracy. He then said "I know a closed mind when I see one" while referring to scientific colleagues. After leaving the stand, he told reporters that the judge wasn't paying attention and was obviously biased. Creationists' Scientific Publications : Eugenie Scott and Henry Cole used SCI-SEARCH to do a 3-year scan of over 1000 scientific and technical journals looking for articles written by creationists. Only 6 papers from creationists were published. None of the papers were about creationism. They then checked submissions to journals and discovered that out of 135000 submitted manuscripts only 18 covered creationism. All were rejected for several faults including "ramblings", "no coherent arguments", "high-school theme quality", "tendentious essay not suitable for publication anywhere", "more like a long letter than a referenced article", "no systematic treatment", "does not define terms", and "flawed arguments". Scott and Cole ended up concluding "from the reviewers' comments, it appears that laymen rather than professional scientists are submitting the few articles that have surfaced the last 3 years". "... when only 18 articles are submitted to 68 journals in three years, and those articles are submitted apparently by persons not skilled in established scientific methodology and theory, it is inappropriate to invoke censorship." [4] REFERENCES [1] On Creationism Free Inquiry, Spring 1982, volume 2, number 2, page 4. [2] Creationist Pseudoscience the Skeptical Inquirer, Fall 1983, volume VIII, number 1, page 32. [3] personal check via phone calls. [4] Evidence for Scientific Creationism Science, May 17, 1985, Vol. 228, page 837. NOTES [5] Warning, this "for example" was not randomly chosen. [6] Donald Chittick is also a member of the (idiotic) ICR. RECOMMENDED READING Repealing the Enlightenment, about the 1982 Arkansas equal-time trial. Harpers, April 1982, pp. 38-78. Creationism in Schools The Decision in McLean verses the Arkansas Board of Education. Science, February 19, 1982, volume 215, pp. 934-943. Reviews of Thirty-One Creationist Books, National Center for Science Education, 1984. Evolutionists Confront Creationists Proceedings of the 63rd Annual Meeting of the Pacific Division, American Association for the Advancement of Science, April, 1984, volume 1, part 3. Science and Creationism : A View from the National Academy of Sciences, 1984. Science as a Way of Knowing - Evolutionary Biology American Zoologist, volume 24, number 2, 1984. Crusade of the Credulous California Academy of Sciences Press, 1986. Meanwhile, I'm saving up box-tops and when I have enough, I'll get some degrees and become a scientific type person just like those creationists.


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank