Isaaci Asimov himself was discriminated against because he was a Jew. In spite of his imm

Master Index Current Directory Index Go to SkepticTank Go to Human Rights activist Keith Henson Go to Scientology cult

Skeptic Tank!

Isaaci Asimov himself was discriminated against because he was a Jew. In spite of his immense talent, he was refused admittance to medical school because there was a quota on Jews. I myself would take serious issue with this systematic anti-semitism in America, but he saw it a bit differently than I had ever thought of-till I was researching the program we did on him the other day. Asimov said: I really dislike Judaism....It's a form of particularly pernicious nationalism. I don't want humanity divided into these litle groups that are firmly convinced, each one, that it is better than the others. Judaism is the prototype of the "I'm better than you" group-we are the ones who invented this business of the only God. It's not just that we have our God and you have your God. I feel a deep and abiding historic guilt about that. And every once in a while, when I'm careful, I think that the reasons Jews have been persecuted as much as they have has been to punish them having invented this pernicious doctrine. Zionism cannot be separated from this problem that he points out, and neither can Islam or Christianity. Both are outgrowths of Judaism, and neither dropped this notion that they have the only valid religion and that all others are lesser creeds. Perhaps the reason why some of us who criticize Israel first are people who expect more out of Israel than out of the Palestinians. Certainly the tactic of Palestinians killing other Palestinians for the least little bit of compromise is abhorrent, as is the killing and capture of hostages. I just don't think that people become this way for no reason, just as Zionism wasn't pursued so seriously after the holocaust for no reason. The problem is that these reasons were so consuming. They left little room for the realization of what other people's problems were, and the potential for working together toward common goals instead of endless conflict. Such realization is necessary for peace. Creeds which induce fanatical belief don't allow this process to take place. So what's the REAL penalty for a Jew killing an Arab? What's the REAL penalty for ordering troops to break the limbs of Palestinian youth? It appears the penalty is to be elected Prime Minister. Who got jailed for killing all those Palestinians on the Temple Mount? Whose water is being taken by the other? It goes on and on, it seems. But maybe the recent elections will make a little difference. It's a little difficult to say these things about Israel when we have the very same problems here in America, as can be pointed to in the case of Rodney King and a host of others. Truly the leadership, and the criminal justice system, of our nation and the nation of Israel are of the same ilk. It doesn't seem to do much good to criticize either it seems, and in fact just causes backlash. I must be crazy for doing it. I also criticize people like Rodney King and Yasser Arafat, BTW. There just aren't too many people willing to be reasonable in this world.


E-Mail Fredric L. Rice / The Skeptic Tank